Menu

Argument: Burqa undermines identity, responsibility, social compact

Issue Report: Ban on Muslim burqa and niqab

Support

Jean Francois-Cope. “Tearing away the veil.” New York Times. May 4th, 2010: “in both France and the United States, we recognize that individual liberties cannot exist without individual responsibilities. This acknowledgment is the basis of all our political rights. We are free as long as we are responsible individuals who can be held accountable for our actions before our peers. But the niqab and burqa represent a refusal to exist as a person in the eyes of others. The person who wears one is no longer identifiable; she is a shadow among others, lacking individuality, avoiding responsibility.”

Jean Francois-Cope. “Tearing away the veil.” New York Times. May 4th, 2010: “Through a legal ban, French parliamentarians want to uphold a principle that should apply to all: the visibility of the face in the public sphere, which is essential to our security and is a condition for living together. A few extremists are contesting this obvious fact by using our democratic liberties as an instrument against democracy. We have to tell them no.”

Jean Francois-Cope. “Tearing away the veil.” New York Times. May 4th, 2010: “Individual liberty is vital, but individuals, like communities, must accept compromises that are indispensable to living together, in the name of certain principles that are essential to the common good. […] Let’s take one example: The fact that people are prohibited from strolling down Fifth Avenue in the nude does not constitute an attack on the fundamental rights of nudists. Likewise, wearing headgear that fully covers the face does not constitute a fundamental liberty.”